Gathering four strands beneath the jaw on a halter or hackamore, and making a four-strand diamond knot out of one line.
When
Unknown; Ashley says the method arrived in the US Southwest right after the Spanish–American War ended.
Who devised it
Unknown; Ashley says the method began on the pampas of South America.
Where the name comes from
From the Spanish 'fiador', which in the United States was corrupted to 'Theodore knot' (Wikipedia compares this with cowboys turning jáquima into 'hackamore' and mecate into 'McCarty'). A guess passed on by Ashley ties the change to Theodore Roosevelt's visit to the Southwest.
Its story
The fiador knot is a symmetrical decorative knot of horse tack, found on rope halters, on hobbles and on the part of some hackamores called the fiador; on a hackamore it keeps the fiador's four strands gathered beneath the horse's jaw. In the traditional description that Wikipedia takes from Ashley, it is a diamond knot of four strands where six of the eight ends turn back and re-enter the knot, which is why one line is enough to make it. Ashley writes that the method began on the pampas of South America, passed through Mexico and reached the cattle country of the US Southwest right after the Spanish–American War ended; he also passes on a guess by Philip Ashton Rollins that the Spanish word 'fiador' was turned into 'Theodore' to honour Theodore Roosevelt, who toured the Southwest not long after that war. It has a reputation for difficulty: cowboys reportedly charged money to tie it, and Ashley filed it among his trick knots. Animated Knots says that Ashley's drawing and text are not enough to learn the traditional form, and that the knot can be made by first building a precursor and then converting it; Wikipedia likewise notes that recent sources show a simpler route through a flat precursor.
Where a knot must be tied quickly, and for load-bearing connections; the sources describe it only in horse tack and as decoration.
Weakness
It is hard to tie: a wrongly arranged precursor, the wrong bights, or pulling them the wrong way all fail to produce the knot, and when the strands on its loose face are spread, the knot readily loses its shape and opens up.